Should national team selection go by current form rather than reputation?

Every time a big name is picked despite a poor run, or dropped after one bad series, fans argue about it.

The case for

• It rewards merit and keeps everyone hungry.

• Young players in form deserve their chance.

The case against

• A few matches are a small sample; class is permanent.

• Experience matters in big tournaments and pressure moments.

Where do you stand? Vote, then share your opinion - and say what would change your mind.